How to read this index
The third of the collection indexes, after The 200 and The Modern 200. One line per claim, the archive's evidence label, and a link where a dossier goes deeper. This list is unusual in one way: the majority of its entries are genuine scholarly arguments, so the interesting distinction is not real versus fake but settled versus still open.
The labels: Documented — the thing exists or happened, on the record. Live debate — real evidence, real specialists, no settled answer. Fringe — no positive evidence, often unfalsifiable in practice. Debunked — tested and failed, or a known hoax. Fiction — invented story, legend or film plot, labelled as such rather than as a claim about the world.
What this collection gets wrong
Most of these entries are fair summaries. Eleven are not, and the index marks them rather than repeating the framing:
- Atlantis in Antarctica needs a crustal shift that does not happen, and ice cores show the Antarctic sheet has been in place for tens of millions of years.
- Mu and Kumari Kandam have no sunken continent behind them: the shelves are drowned land, but no cities, no population, no continent.
- The Mohenjo-daro "atomic blast" is vitrified brick from kilns and slag, and the "radioactive skeletons" were never measured.
- Gunung Padang: the 2023 pyramid paper was disputed by geologists and has been retracted; the hill is a terraced site, not a 20,000-year-old building.
- The Ica stones were carved by locals who demonstrated it, and the Acámbaro figurines came from paid diggers working for one collector.
- The Kensington Runestone and Bat Creek stone are 19th-century fabrications; the runes are modern Swedish and the "Hebrew" is not Hebrew.
- The Grand Canyon citadel appears in one 1909 newspaper article and in no Smithsonian record, excavation report or catalogue.
- Pakal's lid is a maize-and-underworld scene; the "rocket" reading depends on ignoring the tree at its centre.
- Tutankhamun's hidden chambers: repeated radar and neutron scans between 2015 and 2020 found no doorways.
- Salting Carthage has no ancient source, and Nero fiddling is doubly impossible — the violin did not exist and he was at Antium.
- The Library of Alexandria was not destroyed in a single fire; it decayed over centuries of funding cuts and civil war.
Two entries also deserve promotion rather than correction: Homo floresiensis is no longer disputed as a species, and Zealandia was formally described as a continent in 2017.