Ten minutes: one claim, properly
Pick something you already have an opinion about. Flat Earth is the best test case in the archive, because the evidence is something you can check with a stick, a friend and a phone. Read the dossier to the end — past the claim, past the response, into the source list — then open one of those sources and see whether it says what the page says it says.
If you only look at one other thing, make it the numbers page: how the 150 claims in the master list are labelled, and how much sourcing stands behind each dossier. Numbers are a fast honesty check on any publication, including this one.
An evening: the four labels
Every claim in this archive carries one of four labels. They are not a scale of how interesting a claim is, and they are not a judgement of the people who believe it. They describe the state of the evidence.
Read in this order for the clearest contrast: Proven Conspiracies (documented), Lead and Crime (live debate), Hollow Earth (fringe), the Cardiff Giant (debunked with a receipt).
A week: pick a theme, follow it
The archive is now sorted into seven themes, each with its own page: browse the taxonomy. A theme is the right unit for a long visit, because neighbouring dossiers share evidence. Reading the Ice Wall, Hollow Earth and the Larger Globe together teaches you more than the same three read apart.
For the completist: the master list is 150 claims with one verdict each and a filter; the single-volume edition collects every dossier into one page you can print.
Anatomy of a dossier
Every page is built the same way, so you can read the structure rather than hunting for it.
- Kicker and label. Where and when the claim comes from, and its evidence label.
- Standfirst. The claim in one sentence, fairly stated.
- The claim, in its own terms. Named proponents and their strongest argument, not a straw man.
- The response. What the evidence actually shows, with links to the tests.
- What remains open. The honest residue — every page has one.
- Sources. Every claim traceable to a named, linked source at the foot of the page.
- Facts panel. Dates, status and the one detail worth remembering.
Five questions for any claim
These work on this archive as well as on anything else you read.
- What would change my mind? If nothing could, it is not a claim about the world.
- Who says so, and how would they know? A named source with access beats an anonymous authority.
- Is the evidence primary or second-hand? A photograph, a file, a measurement — or a retelling of a retelling?
- Does the explanation need a cover-up to survive? If yes, the bar for evidence goes up, not down.
- What does the mainstream account actually say? Not the version in the conspiracy video — the version in the paper.
Nothing here asks you to believe anything. Every page ends with the sources it used, so the archive is a set of arguments you can check rather than a set of conclusions you have to accept.