The register57 claims · five categories
Every Claim, and How It's Filed
The whole archive on one page: claim, label, and where to read it. Four labels, used the same way everywhere.
Key. Documented primary records or peer review · Live debate serious people disagree · Fringe claim no evidence offered · Debunked tested and failed. A claim can be interesting and still be filed as debunked — that is the point of the register.
I · Space, physics and realityThe ones that start with an equation
| Claim | Label | Where and why |
|---|---|---|
| Many-worlds interpretation | Documented | Everett, 1957. Mainstream physics; an interpretation, not a proven fact — no experiment yet separates it from rivals. |
| Simulation hypothesis | Live debate | Bostrom's trilemma. A rigorous argument that does not establish its third horn. |
| Quantum immortality | Live debate | Derived from many-worlds; requires dropping the Born rule and a "you" that crosses branches. |
| One-electron universe | Debunked | Wheeler to Feynman, 1940. Abandoned by both; no account of particle number. |
| Boltzmann brains | Live debate | A working reductio in cosmology, used against eternal-fluctuation models. |
| Dark forest theory | Live debate | Liu Cixin, 2008. A fiction premise with two stipulated axioms. |
| Zoo hypothesis | Live debate | Ball, Icarus, 1973. In the dark forest dossier; same untestability, opposite motive. |
| Black Knight satellite | Debunked | The 1998 photograph shows a thermal blanket lost on a spacewalk. |
| Inner sun / dual suns | Fringe claim | From hollow-Earth literature; no observation supports a second local star. |
| Grandfather paradox | Live debate | A real problem for closed timelike curves; Novikov's self-consistency is the main answer. |
| White holes | Live debate | The time-reversed black-hole solution; never observed, and the Big Bang is not one. |
| Project Blue Beam | Fringe claim | In the UFO dossier: a hologram apocalypse that absorbs every future observation. |
II · Mind, philosophy and natureThe ones that start with a thought
| Claim | Label | Where and why |
|---|---|---|
| Last Thursdayism | Fringe claim | Unfalsifiable by construction — the page argues that is the lesson, not the claim. |
| Solipsism | Fringe claim | In the Last Thursdayism dossier; a serious position that cannot be lived or tested. |
| The Egg | Documented | Andy Weir, 2009 — documented as fiction, accurately credited, and older than him as an idea. |
| Roko's Basilisk | Fringe claim | A Pascal's mugging that spreads by warning about itself. |
| Electromagnetic soul | Fringe claim | Real fields, real measurements, and a leap the numbers cannot carry. |
| Bicameral mind | Live debate | Jaynes, 1976. Influential; no neurological mechanism, and ancient texts contradict it. |
| Stoned ape hypothesis | Fringe claim | Real pharmacology, real brain-size change, no evidence linking them. |
| The Bloop | Debunked | In Underwater Worlds; NOAA attributes it to icequakes, and it was never in the Mariana Trench. |
| Mass psychogenic illness | Documented | Strasbourg 1518, Tanganyika 1962, Salem — with the records. |
| False memory (Mandela effect) | Live debate | Named 2009; explained by memory research rather than timelines. |
| Gaia hypothesis | Live debate | Strong version rejected (no unit of selection); weak version is now Earth system science. |
III · History and geographyThe ones that start with a document
| Claim | Label | Where and why |
|---|---|---|
| Phantom time (614–911 AD) | Debunked | Tree rings, eclipses, Chinese annals and coins all close the gap. |
| Hollow Earth | Debunked | Seismology, gravity and boreholes; the full dossier. |
| Expanding Earth | Debunked | Lost its mechanism to plate tectonics; the page explains why it faded. |
| Continental drift | Documented | Wegener 1912, ridiculed, then vindicated — the archive's founding example. |
| Lemuria, Mu, Kumari Kandam | Live debate | Invented continents vs real drowned land: Zealandia, Sundaland, Doggerland. |
| Tartaria / mud flood | Debunked | Building styles, census records and photographs; needs evidence destroyed to survive. |
| Giant skeletons | Debunked | Cardiff Giant and the rest; the photographs are the evidence against them. |
| Ancient astronauts | Debunked | Real monuments, invented mechanism, no prediction. |
| Silurian hypothesis | Documented | Frank & Schmidt, 2018 — published, peer-reviewed, and explicitly not a claim that one existed. |
IV · Internet lore and pop cultureThe ones that start with a post
| Claim | Label | Where and why |
|---|---|---|
| Dead internet theory | Live debate | Bots are ~half of traffic; "most readers are bots" does not follow. |
| The Backrooms | Documented | One 2019 photograph and one paragraph — openly fiction, and better for it. |
| The Wyoming Incident | Debunked | No FCC record, no station log; contrast the real Max Headroom hijacking of 1987. |
| Polybius | Debunked | First appears around 2000; no cabinet, no photograph, no operator. |
| Pixar Theory | Documented | Negroni, 2013 — labelled as fan criticism, and the Easter eggs are real. |
| Rugrats theory | Debunked | Reinterpretation with nothing behind it; authorship points the other way. |
| Paul is dead | Debunked | No crash, no funeral, no gap in a documented public life. |
| The 27 Club | Debunked | A list, not a distribution: age 27 is where these deaths peak anyway. |
| Mummy's curse | Debunked | Tested as a cohort study in the BMJ, 2002: no effect. |
| Amityville, Hope Diamond | Debunked | SPR files it as a hoax; the Smithsonian dates the diamond's curse to 1908. |
| Creepypasta and Slender Man | Documented | Fiction with a documented origin — and documented real-world harm in 2014. |
| SpongeBob seven sins | Debunked | Seven characters, seven sins — some mapping always fits. Never confirmed by the writers. |
| Ed, Edd n Eddy purgatory | Debunked | Skin tones and absent adults are animation conventions, not evidence of death. |
V · Claims that turned out to be trueThe ones where the paranoia was right
| Claim | Label | Where and why |
|---|---|---|
| MKUltra | Documented | CIA, 1953–73; exposed by the Church Committee and FOIA. |
| Tuskegee syphilis study | Documented | 1932–72; penicillin withheld; exposed in 1972. |
| Operation Mockingbird | Documented | Church Committee and Bernstein, 1977. |
| Operation Northwoods | Documented — proposed, rejected | Signed proposal, declassified 1997, never executed. "They discussed it" ≠ "they did it". |
| Nayirah testimony | Documented | Fabricated incubator testimony, arranged through a PR firm. |
| The Business Plot | Documented | Butler's testimony, McCormack–Dickstein report, no prosecutions. |
| Watergate | Documented | The benchmark: documents and tapes outran the cover-up. |
| COINTELPRO, Tonkin, Iran-Contra, tobacco | Documented | Four more, each with the document that proved it. |
| Bohemian Grove | Documented | A real club in a real forest. Real ≠ shadow government. |
| Germ theory / Semmelweis | Documented | Vindicated after his death — and a case of consensus inertia, not conspiracy. |
| Hope Diamond provenance | Documented | A real object with a real paper trail — and a manufactured curse. |
| Operation Paperclip | Documented | Over 1,600 German scientists recruited; Nazi records sanitised. Confirmed in government files. |





