Two different meanings of "unsolved"
A conjecture is not a controversy. The Riemann Hypothesis has no camps — it has a statement nobody can prove, and a very large amount of confirming computation. A medical hypothesis usually has camps, because the evidence is observational, confounded and slow. Treating the two the same is how mathematics gets mistaken for opinion and medicine for certainty.
The labels: Open problem — precisely stated, neither proved nor disproved; the note gives how far it has been checked. Documented — the phenomenon is on record. Live debate — real evidence on both sides, no settled answer. Fringe — no positive evidence. Debunked — tested and failed.
Where this collection overstates things
Six framings need correcting, and the entries above carry the correction rather than the original wording:
- The abc conjecture is not a standoff between equal camps. Mochizuki's proof has not been accepted by the field; most specialists who examined it found a gap they could not resolve, and the debate is about whether the theory can be read at all.
- The inscribed square problem is not open for "any continuous closed loop". It is false for curves that cross themselves; the open case is simple closed curves, and it is proven for smooth ones.
- P vs NP would not straightforwardly "break encryption". Factoring is not known to be NP-complete; a proof of P ≠ NP would not by itself tell you factoring is hard.
- Chronic Lyme is not a symmetrical disagreement. Prolonged antibiotics have been tested and failed, with documented harms — while post-treatment symptoms are real and deserve treatment.
- The serotonin critique is not evidence that antidepressants do not work. The 2022 review is about the causal story psychiatry told the public, not about drug efficacy.
- The metabolic theory of cancer: the Warburg effect is genuine and clinically used; the leap to "cancer is metabolic, not genetic" and to diet as treatment is not supported by trials.
One entry deserves more credit than a list usually gives it: the carbohydrate–insulin model is a serious hypothesis with controlled trials against it, not a fringe claim — it is wrong or incomplete in a way that is still scientifically productive.