The settled part
Lynn Margulis's endosymbiotic theory was resisted for years and is now standard: mitochondria descend from an alphaproteobacterium, and chloroplasts from a cyanobacterium. The evidence is genomic, structural and phylogenetic — mitochondria have their own DNA, bacterial-type ribosomes and a double membrane.
This is one of the archive's clean cases: a once-fringe idea that became textbook science because the molecular evidence arrived.
The open part
Who was the host? The traditional picture is an archaeon that engulfed a bacterium. An alternative, the 'inside-out' model, argues the bacterium was engulfed by protrusions of an archaeal cell. A third possibility is that the host was already complex, with a cytoskeleton and internal membranes.
When? Estimates range from about 1.6 to 2.7 billion years ago, depending on which fossils and molecular clocks you trust. The oldest uncontroversial eukaryote fossils are around 1.6 billion years old; some claims push earlier.
Was it one event or several? Asgard archaea — discovered in deep-sea sediments — carry many 'eukaryotic' genes, which suggests the host lineage was already part-way there before the merger.
The merger is the reason complex life exists. A cell with mitochondria can generate far more energy per gene than a bacterium can, which is the basis of Lane and Martin's 'energetics' argument for why complexity arose once.
It is also a case study in how a theory becomes accepted: not by argument, but by a new kind of evidence — in this case, DNA sequencing of organisms nobody had cultured.
What the label means
'Live debate' here is about mechanism and timing, not about whether the merger happened. That is worth keeping separate, in the same way that the Gaia hypothesis has a settled core and an unsettled extension.
The next decade of work is comparative genomics of Asgard archaea and better constraints on the fossil record — neither of which is likely to overturn the endosymbiotic theory itself.
Sources for this page
- Wikipedia, “Symbiogenesis” — Margulis, evidence, receptionen.wikipedia.org
- Spang et al. (2015), Asgard archaea and the origin of eukaryoteswww.nature.com
- Lane & Martin (2010), the energetics of genome complexitywww.nature.com
- Wikipedia, “Eukaryote” — fossils and molecular datingen.wikipedia.org