The Larger World ArchiveClaims · Sources · Evidence
Space, physics and the cosmosLive debateQuantum foundations · 1986 – present

Objective Collapse

Standard quantum theory says the wavefunction collapses when measured, and never says what a measurement is. Objective-collapse models replace that with real physics: the collapse happens on its own.

A laser optics bench. Precision interferometry and levitated mirrors are where objective-c
A laser optics bench. Precision interferometry and levitated mirrors are where objective-collapse models are being tested against standard quantum theory. Image: US Air Force · Public domain — Wikimedia Commons.

The measurement problem, stated plainly

Schrödinger's equation is smooth and deterministic. It spreads a particle's possibilities into a superposition. Then, at measurement, we are told to collapse the superposition to one outcome — a rule that appears nowhere in the equation and has no definition of 'measurement' attached.

Copenhagen-style teaching says not to ask. Objective-collapse models say: add a term to the equation that makes superpositions of sufficiently large, sufficiently spread-out objects collapse spontaneously, at random, with a fixed rate.

The models

GRW (1986). Ghirardi, Rimini and Weber proposed that each particle has a tiny probability per second of its wavefunction spontaneously localising. For one particle the rate is so low it is never seen; for 10²³ particles acting together, collapse is effectively instantaneous.

Continuous models. Later versions (CSL) make the collapse a continuous stochastic process rather than discrete jumps, which handles identical particles and relativity better.

Diósi–Penrose. A different route: gravity itself causes collapse when a superposition of mass distributions becomes distinguishable by its own gravitational field. This makes the collapse rate mass-dependent, which is what experiments test.

What makes this testable, and what the tests say

Because collapse is a physical process, it adds a little noise and heat. Very small systems are protected by being small; the prediction is a threshold somewhere between molecular and visible scales.

Underground experiments at Gran Sasso, levitated optomechanics, and cryogenic cantilevers have all been used to rule out chunks of parameter space. So far the predictions of standard quantum mechanics keep winning, which pushes the collapse parameters into harder-to-reach territory — but has not closed them.

This is the rare foundations debate that could end with a measurement. That is why the archive treats it as live rather than philosophical.

Why it is in the archive

It is the clean counterexample to 'quantum theory means everything is uncertain until you look.' Here the uncertainty is real and physical, and looking has nothing to do with it.

See also pilot-wave theory, which keeps the wave and removes collapse entirely — the two proposals are opposite solutions to the same problem.

Sources for this page

  • Wikipedia, “Objective-collapse theory” — GRW, CSL, Diósi–Penroseen.wikipedia.org
  • Ghirardi, Rimini & Weber (1986), Physical Review D 34, 470doi.org
  • Bassi et al. (2013), Reviews of Modern Physics 85, 471 — models and experimental testsdoi.org
  • Donadi et al. (2021), Nature Physics — underground test of gravity-related collapsedoi.org