The Larger World ArchiveClaims · Sources · Evidence
Earth, geology and hidden geographyLive debatePalaeontology · 1872 – present

The Ediacaran Organisms

For decades, the Ediacaran fossils were a taxonomic orphanage: too big to be microbes, too weird to be animals. Molecular evidence has now placed some of them, without settling the group.

<em>Dickinsonia</em> from the Flinders Ranges, South Australia. Cholesterol preserved in f
Dickinsonia from the Flinders Ranges, South Australia. Cholesterol preserved in fossils of this genus is the strongest evidence that it was an animal. Image: cprevot (https://www.geodiversite.net/auteur193) · CC BY-SA 3.0 — Wikimedia Commons.

The organisms

The Ediacaran biota appeared after the Cryogenian glaciations and before the Cambrian explosion. The most famous is Dickinsonia, a flattened oval with rib-like segments, up to a metre across, with no mouth, gut, or obvious organs. Others include Charnia, frond-like and anchored to the sea floor, and Kimberella, which left scrape marks consistent with grazing.

They are found worldwide, often in sandstone beds that record microbial mats, and they vanish from the record before the Cambrian.

The competing readings

Early animals. The mainstream view now, supported by cholesterol biomarkers preserved in Dickinsonia fossils (Bobrovskiy et al., 2018), which indicate animal-grade sterol synthesis. Kimberella's grazing traces and Ikaria's putative bilaterian features support it.

Vendobionts. Adolf Seilacher argued they were a separate kingdom of quilted, fluid-filled organisms with no modern descendants — an experiment in large size that failed.

Other options. Retallack proposed some were land-dwelling lichens; others have suggested giant protists or colonial organisms. Each has fossil evidence in favour and problems with it.

What is agreed

Agreed: they were large, soft-bodied, mostly sessile, and ecologically important — the first complex ecosystems with tiered structure.

Agreed: at least some were animals, or stem-group animals, based on biomarker chemistry.

Disputed: whether the whole assemblage is one clade, several, or a mix of animals and non-animals; and how much of the 'weirdness' is preservational.

The archive labels this live debate rather than documented because the flagship claim — 'these are the first animals' — is only partly established.

Why it is in the archive

Because the deep past is where the fringe and the real science overlap most confusingly: the same fossils appear in creationist timelines, in 'ancient alien' seed-life stories, and in serious palaeontology.

See the Ancient collection for the pseudo-historical uses of deep time.

Sources for this page

  • Wikipedia, “Ediacaran biota” — taxa, preservation, interpretationsen.wikipedia.org
  • Bobrovskiy et al. (2018), Science — sterols identify Dickinsonia as an animaldoi.org
  • Droser & Gehling (2015), PNAS — the advent of animals, the Ediacaran viewdoi.org
  • Retallack (2013), Nature — the case for Ediacaran life on landdoi.org