The Larger World ArchiveClaims · Sources · Evidence
Space, physics and the cosmosLive debateStellar astronomy · 2015 – present

Tabby’s Star

A star 1,470 light years away keeps dimming in strange, uneven ways. A comet swarm was the first guess, dust the current one — and a megastructure was never more than a headline.

A light curve of KIC 8462852 from late 2019. The irregular, asymmetric dips are the observ
A light curve of KIC 8462852 from late 2019. The irregular, asymmetric dips are the observation that made the star famous — and they are now attributed to dust. Image: Bruce L. Gary · CC0 — Wikimedia Commons.

The observation

Tabby’s Star (KIC 8462852, now Boyajian's Star) was flagged in the Kepler data by citizen scientists in 2015. Its light dips by up to 22 per cent, irregularly, and the dips are asymmetric — unlike a planet transit, which is periodic and symmetric.

Long-term photometry from photographic plates suggested a slow decline over a century as well, which made the star look even stranger, though that claim has been disputed on the basis of plate calibration.

The explanations

Dust and debris. The leading explanation. Dust absorbs starlight and re-emits it in the infrared; a 2018 campaign that caught the star dimming in real time found the dimming was wavelength-dependent — blue light was blocked more than red — exactly as dust grains of the wrong size would do. A transiting planet or an opaque structure would block all wavelengths equally.

Comet fragments. A family of comets breaking up on an eccentric orbit. Consistent with some of the data, but hard to keep supplied.

Instrumental effects. Kepler's calibration and the star's rotation have both been proposed as contributors.

The alien megastructure, honestly

The idea — an artificial swarm of collectors — was raised by the star's discoverers only to be dismissed, and then repeated endlessly. It made one class of prediction: no wavelength-dependent dimming, plus excess mid-infrared emission from waste heat.

Neither was found. Radio searches for narrowband signals found nothing. The dust signature is now measured, and the megastructure hypothesis is not supported.

The interesting part is why it spread: an unexplained dip in a star's light is a genuine puzzle, and 'scientists baffled' plus 'aliens?' is a stable media formula. The archive keeps the page because correcting it is useful.

What it teaches

That an unexplained observation can be a real scientific puzzle while its most dramatic interpretation is already excluded by ordinary physics.

That the decisive evidence was often the least dramatic: measuring which wavelengths dimmed, not listening for signals.

Sources for this page

  • Wikipedia, “Tabby’s Star” — light curve, hypotheses, observationsen.wikipedia.org
  • Boyajian et al. (2016), MNRAS — the original studydoi.org
  • Boyajian et al. (2018), ApJL — the first post-Kepler dipsdoi.org
  • Wikipedia, “KIC 8462852” — observation historyen.wikipedia.org