Master document 150 claims · one verdict each
The Master List
Everything on the list, in one place: a verdict, a reason in a sentence, and a link where a full dossier exists. Entries with no link to a dossier are catalogued but not yet written up — that is a to-do, not a verdict.
Key: DOC documented · DEB live debate · FRI fringe, no evidence · DEB'D tested and failed. A verdict on a claim is not a verdict on the people who believe it.
All 150
Documented
Live debate
Fringe
Debunked
01 · Space, physics and the cosmos Where the equations do the arguing
# Claim Verdict Note / where
1 Great Filter DEB A framing device, not a finding — see Dark Forest .
2 False vacuum decay DEB A real possibility in particle physics; the "any second now" framing is not.
3 Holographic universe DEB Serious theoretical work (AdS/CFT); no experiment yet.
4 Big Crunch DEB Disfavoured by accelerating expansion; not refuted outright.
5 Big Rip DEB Depends on dark energy's equation of state; a scenario, not a prediction.
6 Panspermia DEB Respectable hypothesis; moves the origin question rather than answering it.
7 Directed panspermia FRI Crick's speculation; no evidence of intent, and untestable as stated.
8 Berserker probes FRI Fiction premise (Saberhagen); no probe has been detected.
9 Transcension hypothesis FRI Unfalsifiable; interesting as a story about why silence looks like absence.
10 Planet Nine DEB Real, active astronomy — inferred from orbits, not yet seen.
11 Nemesis (death star) DEB'D Periodicity claim failed; surveys found no companion. See Suns & Stars .
12 Hollow Moon DEB'D Seismology from Apollo rules it out. See Hollow Earth .
13 Rare Earth DEB A serious argument in the Fermi debate, not a solved question.
14 White hole cosmology DEB Baby-universe models exist; no observation. See Time Paradoxes .
15 Chronology protection DEB Hawking's conjecture, 1992 — unproven. Dossier .
16 Black Knight satellite DEB'D A thermal blanket. Dossier .
17 Boltzmann brains DEB Dossier .
18 Simulation hypothesis DEB Dossier .
19 Many-worlds DOC Mainstream interpretation. Dossier .
20 Quantum immortality DEB Dossier .
21 One-electron universe DEB'D Abandoned by Wheeler and Feynman. Dossier .
22 Zoo hypothesis DEB In Dark Forest .
23 Dark forest DEB Fiction premise. Dossier .
24 Silurian hypothesis DOC Peer-reviewed thought experiment. Dossier .
02 · Time, reality and philosophy Where the argument is the point
# Claim Verdict Note / where
25 Grandfather paradox DEB Dossier .
26 Bootstrap paradox DEB In the same dossier.
27 Eternal return FRI Nietzsche's thought experiment; not a cosmological model.
28 Presentism DEB A live position in philosophy of time.
29 Block universe DEB The main rival to presentism; supported by relativity's treatment of simultaneity.
30 Brain in a vat FRI Unfalsifiable. Last Thursdayism .
31 Philosophical zombies FRI A test case for physicalism; no empirical content.
32 Omphalos hypothesis FRI Gosse, 1857. Dossier .
33 Last Thursdayism FRI Dossier .
34 Solipsism FRI Section in Last Thursdayism .
35 Newcomb's paradox DEB Live problem in decision theory — the serious relative of Roko's Basilisk .
36 Sleeping Beauty problem DEB Genuinely disputed among philosophers; no experiment decides it.
37 Retrocausality DEB Discussed in quantum foundations; no demonstrated signalling into the past.
38 Roko's Basilisk FRI Dossier .
39 Egg theory DOC Documented as fiction. Dossier .
03 · Mind, body and psychology Where the evidence is clinical
# Claim Verdict Note / where
40 Collective unconscious DEB Influential in criticism; not a measurable structure. Compare Mass Hysteria .
41 Morphic resonance FRI Sheldrake's claim; no replicable effect in controlled tests.
42 Uncanny valley DOC A robust, replicated effect; the explanation is still argued.
43 Capgras delusion DOC A real clinical syndrome — the origin of "body snatcher" stories.
44 Cotard's syndrome DOC Real, rare, documented; not evidence for the walking dead.
45 Split-brain consciousness DEB Surgery is real; "two minds" is an interpretation. Bicameral Mind .
46 Panpsychism DEB Respectable philosophy of mind; no test. Dossier .
47 Orch-OR (quantum mind) DEB'D Microtubule coherence is not supported in warm wet tissue. EM Soul .
48 Aquatic ape FRI No fossil or archaeological support; rejected by palaeoanthropology. Dossier .
49 Genetic memory FRI Epigenetic effects exist; inherited complex memories do not.
50 Stoned ape FRI Dossier .
51 Bicameral mind DEB Dossier .
52 Mandela effect DEB Dossier .
53 Fruit of the Loom cornucopia DEB'D One of the standard false-memory examples. Dossier .
04 · History, archaeology, geography Where documents and strata decide
# Claim Verdict Note / where
54 Tartaria / mud flood DEB'D Dossier .
55 Younger Dryas impact DEB A real, contested hypothesis in Science and elsewhere; not settled. Flood Myths .
56 Atlantis at the Richat Structure DEB'D The rings are real, the identification is not. Underwater Worlds .
57 Lemuria DEB Dossier .
58 Hyperborea FRI Greek legend, no site. Lost Continents .
59 Bosnian pyramids DEB'D Natural hills with human-made tunnels nearby; geologists and archaeologists agree.
60 Voynich manuscript DEB Genuinely undeciphered; every "solved" claim so far has failed. Unexplained .
61 Antikythera "alien" gearwork DEB'D Greek astronomy, dated and understood. Ancient Astronauts .
62 Pre-Columbian contact DEB Polynesian contact is evidenced; Phoenician and Egyptian voyages are not.
63 Giant cover-up DEB'D Dossier .
64 Shakespeare authorship DEB'D Documents, collaboration studies and the First Folio settle it for historians.
65 Hitler escaped to Argentina DEB'D Soviet dental records, witnesses and declassified files; the FBI investigated and found nothing.
66 Anastasia survived DEB'D DNA identified the remains in 1991–2007.
67 Roanoke / Croatoan DEB Assimilation is the leading reading; the "vanished" framing is the myth.
68 Oak Island money pit DEB'D Two centuries of digging, no treasure; the "flood tunnel" is consistent with natural hydrology.
69 Phantom time DEB'D Dossier .
70 Hollow Earth DEB'D Dossier .
71 Continental drift DOC Vindicated. Larger Globe .
05 · Earth, cryptids and anomalies Where the report is the evidence
# Claim Verdict Note / where
72 Mothman / Silver Bridge DEB'D No causal link; the sightings cluster after publicity. Cryptids .
73 Dyatlov Pass DOC A 2021 Nature -family paper models a slab avalanche; the "mystery" is largely closed.
74 Taos Hum DEB Real reports, unresolved cause, probably heterogeneous. Unexplained .
75 Tunguska DOC Airburst, well modelled. Dossier .
76 Skyquakes / Seneca guns DEB Real sounds; several mundane sources identified.
77 Ball lightning DEB Documented but rare; no accepted mechanism, several lab analogues.
78 Bermuda Triangle DEB'D Base-rate error. Mysteries .
79 Hessdalen lights DEB Monitored for decades; plasma-like, not fully explained.
80 Marfa lights DEB'D Car headlights and atmospheric refraction on the main sightline.
81 Interdimensional Bigfoot FRI Adds an untestable mechanism to an unproven animal. Cryptids .
82 Bloop DEB'D Icequake, not leviathan. Underwater Worlds .
83 Spontaneous human combustion DEB'D The "wick effect" explains the documented cases.
06 · Internet lore, games and pop culture Where authorship is the evidence
# Claim Verdict Note / where
84 Lavender Town syndrome DEB'D No record of the claimed deaths; the creepypasta is the source.
85 Ben Drowned DOC A documented web serial by Alex Hall — fiction with a known author.
86 Herobrine DEB'D Mojang has stated it is not in the game; it began as a 4chan image.
87 Courage "no monsters" FRI Fan reading; the show's own text contradicts it.
88 Ferris Bueller imaginary FRI Fan reading with no production support.
89 Toy Story / Andy's mom FRI Never confirmed; the hat is explained in the films.
90 Grease coma theory FRI Invented after the fact; contradicts the film's own ending.
91 Willy Wonka killer FRI Reading, not text — though Dahl's book is genuinely dark.
92 Bond codename FRI Contradicted by the films' own continuity (wives, childhoods, graves).
93 Aladdin post-apocalyptic FRI The Genie's impressions are the joke, not a timeline.
94 Snowpiercer / Wonka FRI A viral video essay; Bong has not endorsed it.
95 Garfield starvation FRI Built on one 1989 strip; the strip's own context refutes it.
96 Cicada 3301 DOC The puzzles are real and archived; the recruiters are unidentified. Deep Web .
97 "Erratas" algorithm FRI No leaks, no documents, no former employees — an invented keyword.
98 Most mysterious song DOC Solved: FEX, identified in 2024. A real internet mystery with a real ending.
99 Pixar Theory DOC Fan criticism. Dossier .
100 Rugrats theory DEB'D In Pixar Theory .
101 SpongeBob seven sins FRI In Pixar Theory .
102 Ed, Edd n Eddy purgatory FRI In Pixar Theory .
103 Paul is dead DEB'D Dossier .
104 27 Club DEB'D Curses .
105 Polybius DEB'D Urban Legends .
106 Wyoming Incident DEB'D Backrooms .
107 The Backrooms DOC Openly fiction. Dossier .
108 Slender Man DOC Urban Legends .
07 · Modern tech and society Where the business model is the story
# Claim Verdict Note / where
109 Birds Aren't Real DOC Documented satire — and one of the best demonstrations of how a fake movement spreads.
110 Phoebus cartel DOC Real collusion, 1924–39. Planned obsolescence is history, not theory.
111 Phones listening DEB Targeting is real; the microphone claim has never been demonstrated, and the ad-tech explanation is cheaper.
112 Finland doesn't exist FRI Satire, taken seriously by some — a pure test of how far a joke travels.
113 Denver airport DEB'D Murals and tunnels are documented; the New World Order bunker is not.
114 Bielefeld conspiracy FRI German satire from 1994, deliberately absurd.
115 5G mind control / weather DEB'D Non-ionising radiation at those powers cannot do either.
116 Mattress Firm laundering FRI The stores are real; the laundering is inference from empty shops. Retail economics is duller.
117 Subliminal advertising DEB'D Vicary's 1957 study was fabricated; replication failed.
118 Dead internet theory DEB Dossier .
119 Blue Beam FRI In The UFO Files .
08 · Claims that turned out to be true Where the paranoia was right
# Claim Verdict Note / where
120 COINTELPRO DOC Files stolen 1971. Dossier .
121 Operation Sea-Spray DOC 1950 Navy aerosol test over San Francisco; documented in court.
122 Project Sunshine DOC Infant tissue collection for fallout measurement; declassified.
123 Tobacco cover-up DOC Internal documents, litigation. Dossier .
124 Sugar industry lobby DOC 1967 NEJM review funded by the Sugar Research Foundation; documented in 2016.
125 Mafia before 1957 DOC Apalachin raid, 1957 — Hoover's denial collapsed.
126 CIA heart-attack gun DOC Revealed in 1975 Church Committee hearings.
127 CIA and the Dalai Lama DOC Declassified payments to Tibetan resistance; the $180,000 figure is from those files.
128 1953 Iran coup (Ajax) DOC CIA acknowledged it in 2013.
129 PRISM / mass surveillance DOC Snowden, 2013; corroborated by the NSA's own materials.
130 Exxon's climate knowledge DOC Internal projections from the late 1970s; reported 2015–2023.
131 "Gay bomb" proposal DOC A real 1994 USAF lab proposal; never built.
132 Acoustic Kitty DOC Declassified CIA project; abandoned.
133 Lead–crime hypothesis DEB Strong correlation, contested causality — an honest live debate.
134 Dreyfus affair DOC 1894 frame-up, exposed; Zola's J'accuse .
135 MKUltra DOC Dossier .
136 Tuskegee DOC Same dossier.
137 Mockingbird DOC Same dossier.
138 Northwoods DOC Proposed, rejected, never executed.
139 Nayirah testimony DOC Fabricated; exposed by journalists.
140 Business Plot DOC Documented approach; no prosecutions.
141 Watergate DOC The benchmark.
142 Bohemian Grove DOC Secret Societies .
143 Paperclip DOC Dossier .
144 Germ theory / Semmelweis DOC Vindicated after his death.
145 Gulf of Tonkin (second attack) DOC NSA's own history admits it.
146 Dyatlov avalanche DOC 2021 modelling — see entry 73.
147 Phoebus cartel DOC See entry 110.
148 Birds Aren't Real (as satire) DOC See entry 109.
149 Most mysterious song solved DOC See entry 98.
150 Silurian hypothesis (as method) DOC See entry 24.
How to read this page
The verdict is about the claim , not the person. A fringe label means no evidence has been offered that could settle it, not that the believer is stupid. A debunked label means the specific claim was tested and failed — usually after being taken seriously by someone qualified.
Entries with no link have no dossier yet. That is the archive's honest state: 150 claims catalogued, 51 written up in depth. The register at Every Claim is the same content in shorter form.